Read theMandate

Project 2025 › Chapter 17

Department of Justice

Chapter 17 · pp. 545–580 · Gene Hamilton

What this chapter is about

This chapter is about the Justice Department and the FBI. It says both have become political. It wants the FBI cut back and moved under closer control. It says the FBI should not police speech. It also asks for more use of the death penalty.

8 proposals indexed from this chapter.

The document says “shouldWho acts: Attorney GeneralHow: internal managementp. 549 in the PDF
What the document says

“remove the FBI from the Deputy Attorney General’s direct supervision”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 549

The chapter proposes placing the FBI under the general supervision of the Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division, says this can be done through a simple internal reorganization without Congress, and that under no circumstances should the FBI be able to go around the Attorney General or the department's leadership on any matter in its area of responsibility.

What the document actually says

“remove the FBI from the Deputy Attorney General’s direct supervision”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 549
That sentence, in plain words

Take the FBI out from under the number two at the department.

What this is about

The FBI answers to the number two at the Justice Department. The book says it should answer to a different official. That would put it under closer watch.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

The document says “shouldWho acts: Attorney General, PresidentHow: internal managementp. 550 in the PDF
What the document says

“Prohibit the FBI from engaging, in general, in activities related to combating the spread of so-called misinformation and disinformation by Americans who are not tied to any plausible criminal activity.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 550

The chapter says the government has no business policing speech, that the First Amendment prohibits it, and asks for a hard firewall between monitoring online activity for threats or evidence of crime, which it treats as legitimate, and asking or demanding that publishers remove material based on content or viewpoint, which it says the department must not do.

What the document actually says

“Prohibit the FBI from engaging, in general, in activities related to combating the spread of so-called misinformation and disinformation by Americans who are not tied to any plausible criminal activity.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 550
That sentence, in plain words

Stop the FBI working on false claims spread by Americans. Unless a crime is involved.

What this is about

The FBI has worked on false claims spread online. The book says that is not its job. It says the government must not police speech.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

The document says “shouldWho acts: Attorney GeneralHow: internal managementp. 551 in the PDF
What the document says

“The next conservative Administration should eliminate any offices within the FBI that it has the power to eliminate without any action from Congress.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 551

The chapter gives the FBI's Office of General Counsel as its example, saying it holds about 300 attorneys, has been involved in what it calls some of the FBI's most damaging recent scandals, and that these attorneys are not necessary in their current capacity because legal advice should come from department attorneys. It separately asks that field offices be emphasized, funded and rewarded while headquarters staff shrinks, saying the department must value badges over bureaucracy.

What the document actually says

“The next conservative Administration should eliminate any offices within the FBI that it has the power to eliminate without any action from Congress.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 551
That sentence, in plain words

Close any FBI office that can be closed without asking Congress.

What this is about

The FBI has many offices at its headquarters. The book says some can be closed by the department alone. It wants those closed.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

The document says “shouldWho acts: Congress, PresidentHow: legislationp. 552 in the PDF
What the document says

“the next conservative Administration should seek a legislative change to align the FBI Director’s position with those of the heads of all other major departments and agencies.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 552

The FBI Director serves a ten-year term, an arrangement adopted to insulate the post from political pressure. The chapter says the Director must remain politically accountable to the President in the same manner as any other agency head, and frames the change as ensuring prompt political accountability and reining in perceived or actual abuses.

What the document actually says

“the next conservative Administration should seek a legislative change to align the FBI Director’s position with those of the heads of all other major departments and agencies.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 552
That sentence, in plain words

Change the law so the FBI chief is like other agency heads.

What this is about

The FBI chief serves a ten-year term. That was meant to keep the job out of politics. The book says the president should be able to remove him like any other chief.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

The document says “shouldWho acts: DOJHow: internal managementp. 553 in the PDF
What the document says

“Use applicable federal laws to bring federal charges against criminals when local jurisdictions wrongfully allow them to evade responsibility for their conduct.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 553

The chapter says prosecution in most jurisdictions must remain a state and local responsibility, but that the federal government owes a special responsibility to Americans where state and local prosecutors have abdicated that duty. It asks for an increased federal law enforcement presence in such places.

What the document actually says

“Use applicable federal laws to bring federal charges against criminals when local jurisdictions wrongfully allow them to evade responsibility for their conduct.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 553
That sentence, in plain words

Some local prosecutors let people off. Federal law should be used to charge them instead.

What this is about

Most crimes are charged by local prosecutors. The book says some choose not to charge. It says federal prosecutors should step in.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

The document says “shouldWho acts: DOJHow: internal managementp. 554 in the PDF
What the document says

“Administration should therefore do everything possible to obtain finality for the 44 prisoners currently on federal death row.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 554

The chapter says the current crime wave makes deterrence vital, that providing the punishment without ever enforcing it serves neither victims' families nor the defendant, and that the death penalty should be pursued for applicable crimes, particularly heinous crimes involving violence and sexual abuse of children, until Congress says otherwise.

What the document actually says

“Administration should therefore do everything possible to obtain finality for the 44 prisoners currently on federal death row.”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 554
That sentence, in plain words

Forty-four people wait on federal death row. Do all you can to carry those out.

What this is about

Some federal prisoners are sentenced to death. Most sentences are never carried out. The book says they should be.

What has happened
Closely matches

Restoring the Death Penalty and Protecting Public Safety

2025-01-20 · 90 FR 8463

The chapter asked that the Administration do everything possible to obtain finality for those on federal death row and pursue capital punishment for applicable crimes. This order directs that approach.

The document says “should considerWho acts: President, DOJ, DODHow: internal managementp. 555 in the PDF
What the document says

“This could include use of active-duty military personnel and National Guardsmen to assist in arrest operations along the border”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 555

The chapter raises this as part of what it calls a creative and aggressive approach to cartels at the border, and notes that it has not yet been done. It says a forceful approach to interdiction would affect the operations of these organizations and lay the groundwork for prosecutions of their leaders.

What the document actually says

“This could include use of active-duty military personnel and National Guardsmen to assist in arrest operations along the border”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 555
That sentence, in plain words

That could mean using soldiers to help make arrests at the border.

What this is about

Soldiers do not normally arrest people inside the country. The book says they could help at the border. It notes this has not been done before.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

The document says “shouldWho acts: Attorney GeneralHow: internal managementp. 552 in the PDF
What the document says

“The Attorney General should require all U.S. Attorneys to develop a jurisdictional-specific plan”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 552

The chapter asks that the plans be developed wherever possible in coordination with state and local law enforcement to reduce violent crime in each district, and that the Attorney General then hold each US Attorney accountable for achieving actual results.

What the document actually says

“The Attorney General should require all U.S. Attorneys to develop a jurisdictional-specific plan”

Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, p. 552
That sentence, in plain words

Each top prosecutor should write a plan. It should fit their own area.

What this is about

Each region has a top federal prosecutor. The book says each should write a crime plan. Then they would answer for the results.

No action is recorded against this proposal. That is not evidence that none has been taken. See what the tracker does not yet cover.

Share this page

What is indexed here, and what is not

Recommendations on the FBI's place in the department, its work on misinformation, its size and structure, the accountability of its Director, violent crime, capital punishment, cartels and the border.

The chapter's account of specific past cases and controversies, its treatment of the Civil Rights Division and antitrust, and many of its detailed component-level recommendations.

This chapter argues at length that the department has been politicized, citing particular episodes. Those arguments are the chapter's characterizations and are not indexed as proposals or repeated as fact here.